Welcome to Espresso Pizzeria
At Espresso Pizzeria, we create a harmonious blend of tradition and flavor in the heart of Bay Ridge. Our passion for pizza is evident in every slice, especially our margherita, praised for its thin, crispy crust and perfect balance of rich sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil. Though nestled in a cozy corner at 9403 5th Ave, we pride ourselves on delivering an authentic New York experience with rapid, friendly service. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite at the counter or taking a whole pie to enjoy at home, Espresso Pizzeria promises to leave your taste buds delighted and your cravings satisfied.
Espresso Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Wow! Truly a hidden gem. We got the margherita pizza and a square. Hot, crispy, great sauce to cheese ratio, safe to say it hit the spot! Be aware, there’s no seating, but there’s a counter where you can enjoy a slice or you can take it to go.
Their margherita pizza is so fire! Thin crust is crispy with that perfect chew, delicious sauce, fresh mozzarella and proportioned amount of basil. The best pizza I’ve tried in Bay Ridge.
Blink and you'll miss it, but Espresso has become our go to pizza place. Whether we pick up a whole pie or just a few slices, we're never disappointed. I absolutely love their Margherita slice! I also appreciate that even when we get a deluxe pie (hubby's favorite) the crust is always crispy and delicious, never soggy which often happens with a well loaded pizza. Staff is friendly and efficient and I've never waited more than 20 minutes when I've ordered for pick up.
My favorite place for Pizza in all of Bay Ridge! The vibes are 12/10, the decor has barely changed since they opened and it adds so much to the experience. The margarita pie is exceptionally good, you have to try it. Im not one to eat the crust, almost ever, but theirs is perfect. Plus, they have such cheap prices (3.25-3.50 for a slice?!). Also, bonus: COVID-conscious folks, this spot is perfect for grab and go, and even has a window outside you can order and eat from!
The margarita is 10 out of 10. Perfect. Thin sliced. Excellent crust. Robust flavor. Top quality. The plain is just plain old plain New York pizza. No complaints. It fills up your belly. Worth going for a margarita if you are around. Cheers. Great owner. Old school vibes.
Margherita Pizza was phenomenal. Not too oily, not too salty, different ingredients were perfectly spaced on the thin crust that enhanced the overall texture. Incredible slice.
I'm starting to think Manhattan no longer has real New York pizza. I go to this Expresso pizzeria one of dozens of great pizzerias in Brooklyn and it's like going back 30 years, I got a plain, a margarita and a Sicilian and a drink for less than 12. Everything is amazing!, I'm pulling cheese forever, this is NY pizza, not that garbage they're selling the tourist in Manhattan (yes there's very expensive great pizza in Manhattan).
Needed a recommendation for lunch since I don't usually eat down here. Glad some coworkers suggested Espresso. Pizza was great; good classic slices. Pizza chef was friendly too. Left very satisfied and would come back any time.
Location
-
9403 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, United States Hotline: +1 718-833-8750
Welcome to Espresso Pizzeria; a hidden gem nestled at 9403 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209. This local favorite is known for its exceptional pizza and warm, inviting atmosphere, despite a limited seating arrangement. With a phone number of +1 718-833-8750 for orders, this pizzeria has quickly established a reputation for delivering some of the best slices in Bay Ridge.
First and foremost, what makes Espresso Pizzeria stand out is its margherita pizza. Many customers rave about its thin, crispy crust that strikes the perfect balance between crunch and chewiness. Reviewers like Delaney Kepple and Aksana Ni have commented on the superior sauce-to-cheese ratio, which elevates each bite into an exquisite tasting experience. The fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil add an authentic Italian flair that is hard to match.
- Delaney Kepple: "Hot, crispy, great sauce to cheese ratio!"
- Aksana Ni: "The best pizza I’ve tried in Bay Ridge!"
- Cindy C: "Their Margherita slice is a must-try!"
- Julian Jaffe: "The vibes are 12/10!"
- Premm: "Perfect, thin, and robust flavor—a 10 out of 10!”
It's not just the margherita that will excite your palate. The pizzeria also serves a delicious square pizza, and loyal patrons appreciate that even with the additional toppings, the crust remains perfectly crispy without a hint of sogginess. Cindy C highlighted the consistent quality, noting that even a thoroughly loaded deluxe pie retains its integrity.
Despite its size, Espresso Pizzeria has successfully cultivated a warm and friendly atmosphere. Many customers speak highly of the staff, describing them as efficient and welcoming. This makes for a trip that is not only about great food but also enjoyable service. As Julian Jaffe notes, the pizzeria exudes an old-school charm that enhances the entire pizza-eating experience.
In a world where dining options are abundant, Espresso Pizzeria shines brightly. It’s not just a spot to grab a slice; it’s a place where flavors come alive and customers leave satisfied. Don't overlook this charming establishment next time you’re in Bay Ridge. Whether you’re looking to eat in at the counter or take your pizza to go, Espresso Pizzeria promises to hit the spot. Cheers to great pizza and even better experiences!